DHS Skyline TG3 vs Tibhar Evolution EL-S: Which Should You Buy?
| DHS Skyline TG3 | Tibhar Evolution EL-S | |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 8.2/10 | 8.5/10 |
| best_side | forehand | either |
| control | 8.0 | 86 |
| speed | 7.5 | 87 |
| spin | 9.5 | 90 |
| sponge_hardness | 38-40 degrees | medium-hard |
| type | tacky Chinese inverted | tensor |
| weight_uncut_g | 63 | 74 |
We may earn a commission from links on this page. Learn more.
The DHS Skyline TG3 is extremely tacky and generates heavy mechanical spin on loops and serves, delivering a low, kicking loop trajectory that is difficult to counter. It excels at short-game control and offers exceptional value compared to Japanese and European premium rubbers. However, it has a steeper learning curve than other tacky Chinese rubbers, is slow on flat hits, and punishes poor footwork with its low throw angle.
The Tibhar Evolution EL-S achieves a 90/100 spin rating, a 10/100 expert topspin benchmark, and an 86/100 control rating—nearly double the Skyline TG3’s 8.0 control score. The Evolution delivers 87/100 speed and works on any blade type. Both are specialty tools: the Skyline TG3 for advanced close-to-the-table looping with developed Chinese technique; the Evolution EL-S for players seeking that same spin without demanding technique refinement.
Choose the Skyline TG3 if you have developed proper Chinese-style looping technique and want a premium short-game specialist at budget pricing. Choose the Evolution EL-S if you want near-elite short-game performance (9.5/10 rating) with less technique burden and equal forehand-backhand capability.
FAQ
Which rubber is better for serve and short game?
Both excel at serve and short game. The Skyline TG3 delivers heavy mechanical spin through extreme tackiness and is rated excellent for pushes, flicks, and serve variations. The Evolution EL-S is rated 9.5/10 in structured short-game testing and works equally well on forehand and backhand.
Which is faster and better for flat hitting?
The Evolution EL-S is significantly faster (87/100 versus the Skyline TG3’s 7.5/100) and more suitable for flat hitting. The Skyline TG3 is slow on flat hits and smashes without a fast blade and significant effort.
Which has a steeper learning curve?
The Skyline TG3 has a steeper learning curve than even other tacky Chinese rubbers like Hurricane 3, due to its low throw angle that punishes poor footwork. The Evolution EL-S is more forgiving for developing technique.
Are both suitable for penhold players?
Yes. The Skyline TG3 is a strong choice for penhold players seeking sensitivity and serve dominance. The Evolution EL-S works on any blade orientation and is equally accessible to penhold and shakehand players.
What about weight and blade pairing?
The Skyline TG3 is lighter at 63g uncut and best paired with a carbon or fast composite blade. The Evolution EL-S at 74g uncut works on both all-rated and off-rated blades without requiring specialized blade matching.