How We Review

1. Multi-source evidence, always

No review is published with fewer than three independent Chinese-language sources — WeChat equipment columns, Zhihu answers, club forums, e-commerce buyer reviews, and Bilibili tests. One opinion is an anecdote; three or more reveal consensus and genuine disagreement.

2. Synthesis, not translation

We never translate articles. Sources are treated as evidence: we aggregate facts and consensus, flag where reviewers disagree, and write every word ourselves in English.

3. Original analysis on top

Each review adds what no single source contains: our 1–10 rating with reasoning, play-style guidance, and an FAQ distilled from recurring community questions.

4. Quality gates before publishing

Every draft passes automated checks — spec fact-checking against manufacturer data, similarity screening against each source, and attribution completeness — followed by human editorial review.

5. Full attribution

Every review lists the sources it draws from. The communities that produced this knowledge deserve the credit.