Butterfly Dignics 05 vs Victas V>15 Extra: Which Should You Buy?
| Butterfly Dignics 05 | Victas V>15 Extra | |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 9.0/10 | 8.4/10 |
| best_side | both | forehand |
| control | medium-high | 81 |
| speed | high (Butterfly rating 86) | 94 |
| spin | very high (Butterfly rating 85) | 88 |
| sponge_hardness | 40 degrees (Butterfly scale) | 47.5 degrees |
| type | tensor inverted (Spring Sponge X) | inverted |
| weight_uncut_g | 70 | 70 |
We may earn a commission from links on this page. Learn more.
Dignics 05 (9) and Victas V greater-than 15 Extra (8.4) both excel at topspin but differ in focus. Dignics is a complete package: class-leading grip, immense power, outstanding durability, superb blocking, and reliable short game—suitable for advanced attackers across the table. V greater-than 15 Extra prioritizes aggressive forehand topspin with unusual insensitivity to incoming spin, making backspin attacks easier, plus three-gear performance and strong serve game—but demanding on technique and better for forehand specialists.
Choose Dignics 05 if you want all-around excellence, durability, and versatile blocking. Choose V greater-than 15 Extra if you prioritize aggressive forehand looping, want a German tensor below premium Japanese prices, and can tolerate a harder feel that amplifies errors. V greater-than 15 Extra backhand blocking is inconsistent and topsheet durability varies; Dignics maintains performance reliably long-term.
FAQ
Which is better for forehand looping?
V greater-than 15 Extra delivers outstanding forehand topspin speed and spin output. Dignics 05 is excellent but prioritizes all-around balance.
Can I use V greater-than 15 Extra on backhand?
Yes, but backhand blocking can be inconsistent and requires precise angles. Dignics 05 is more reliable on backhand.
Which costs less?
V greater-than 15 Extra is more affordable than Japanese premium alternatives like Tenergy 05. Dignics 05 is one of the priciest rubbers.
Which is forgiving?
Dignics 05 is more forgiving—errors don’t amplify as much. V greater-than 15 Extra’s hard sponge amplifies technique errors.
Which lasts longer?
Dignics 05 is legendary for durability. V greater-than 15 Extra topsheet durability varies and can show accelerated wear.