Stiga Carbonado 45 vs Yasaka Ma Lin Extra Offensive: Which Should You Buy?
| Stiga Carbonado 45 | Yasaka Ma Lin Extra Offensive | |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 8.4/10 | 8.5/10 |
| feel | Moderately stiff with deep reverberating vibrations; more wood-like dwell than typical carbon blades; high throw angle | hard outer + soft core, linear |
| handle | Straight/Flared/Anatomic (coal-grey dyed wood) | FL/ST/AN/CS |
| plies | 7-ply with TeXtreme carbon (5 wood + 2 carbon at 45-degree angle) | 5W (all wood) |
| speed | OFF | OFF |
| thickness_mm | 5.7mm | 5.7 |
| weight_g | 85-91g | 88 |
We may earn a commission from links on this page. Learn more.
Nearly identical ratings (8.4 vs 8.5) mask fundamentally different construction and playing character. The Carbonado, at 8.4, is a seven-ply carbon engineered for loop specialists seeking informative vibrations, high throw angle, and wood-like dwell. It demands advanced technique and physical effort from mid-distance. The Yasaka Ma Lin Extra Offensive, at 8.5, is a pure all-wood OFF blade with hard outer over soft core, delivering outstanding consistency, pinpoint placement, and an exceptional short game. It is lighter and aims at control loopers and traditional Chinese penhold players, not raw speed seekers.
Both blades are linear and demand the player supply power—neither offers carbon’s catapult or borrowed pace. Carbonado rewards topspin specialists with feedback; Extra Offensive rewards control and placement with unbeatable value for close-to-mid-table attacking. Choose Carbonado if you value communicative feedback and have elite endorsement pedigree aspirations. Choose Extra Offensive if you want reliable control, short game excellence, and unbeatable value for a versatile all-wood attack game.
FAQ
Which has the better short game?
Extra Offensive: its hard outer over soft core creates superb short game, easy ball placement, and essentially unbeatable value. Carbonado excels but is slower and demands more.
Which is better for penhold players?
Extra Offensive is purpose-designed for traditional Chinese penhold players and control loopers. Carbonado is shakehand-centric despite working for both.
Which is more forgiving?
Extra Offensive has larger sweet spot and many gears. Carbonado’s informative feel can punish imprecise technique with less margin for error.
Which is easier to learn with?
Extra Offensive: it is lighter, more forgiving, and rewards a wide range of techniques. Carbonado demands aggressive, technically sound stroke and is not beginner-friendly.