Stiga Carbonado 145 vs Tibhar Samsonov Alpha: Which Should You Buy?
| Stiga Carbonado 145 | Tibhar Samsonov Alpha | |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 8.4/10 | 7.8/10 |
| feel | stiff, direct and rather linear with a large sweet spot, but the very thin TeXtreme layers keep the vibration close to a 5-ply all-wood blade | medium-stiff, good dwell time, controllable |
| handle | FL/ST (also offered as Legend and penhold) | FL/ST |
| plies | 5 wood plus 2 TeXtreme carbon (5+2 composite) with the carbon fibers laid at a 45 degree angle for torsional bendability | 5-ply all wood (Limba outer plies, Koto/Ayous middle layers) |
| speed | OFF+ | ALL |
| thickness_mm | 5.7 | 5.9 |
| weight_g | 85 | 85 |
We may earn a commission from links on this page. Learn more.
Stiga Carbonado 145 and Tibhar Samsonov Alpha occupy opposite ends of the intermediate-to-advanced spectrum. Carbonado is a stiff, fast, aggressive carbon blade with wood-like vibration and excellent blocking capability, demanding consistent technique from experienced strikers.
Samsonov is lightweight, all-wood, and extremely forgiving for beginners and all-around blockers. Its close-table control and modest speed make it ideal for foundational learning and extended practice.
These blades serve different skill levels entirely. Carbonado 145 suits confident intermediate-to-advanced attackers; Samsonov suits beginners and developing players. Carbonado is 15-20 times more expensive and demands commensurately better technique. There is minimal direct comparison—each excels in its niche.
FAQ
Can a Samsonov player eventually upgrade to Carbonado 145?
Yes, naturally. Samsonov teaches fundamentals; Carbonado 145 awaits advanced players ready for aggressive performance.
Is Carbonado 145 really worth the premium price?
For advanced players, yes. Carbon speed, wood-like feel, and aggressive capabilities justify cost. For beginners, no.
Which blade is more forgiving?
Samsonov, dramatically. Carbonado 145 is unforgiving. Massive difference in tolerance for imperfect contact.
Can I use Carbonado 145 as a learning blade?
Not recommended. Its demanding nature punishes learning strokes. Use Samsonov for fundamentals, upgrade later.