Butterfly Garaydia ALC vs Stiga Emerald VPS V: Which Should You Buy?
| Butterfly Garaydia ALC | Stiga Emerald VPS V | |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 8.5/10 | 8.3/10 |
| control | — | — |
| feel | Crisp, hard and stiff with a direct, low-vibration touch and a notably low throw arc | Stiff, hard outer surface with medium throw angle and large sweet spot |
| handle | FL | Flared (FL), also available in ST and Chinese pen |
| plies | 5-ply total: 3 wood + 2 Arylate-Carbon (ALC) layers, with an outer carbon construction under a Japanese hinoki surface ply | 5-ply all wood (Ebenholz/dark outer, VPS-treated middle veneers) |
| speed | OFF | OFF+ |
| spin | — | — |
| thickness_mm | 6.9 | 6.2 |
| type | OFF | — |
| weight_g | 83 | 98 |
We may earn a commission from links on this page. Learn more.
Butterfly Garaydia ALC combines outer arylate-carbon construction with very low throw arc excelling at blocking and near-table control, crisp stiff feel, and outstanding stability. Advanced topspin attackers playing close-to-mid distance benefit from proven near-table mastery. Stiga Emerald VPS V offers genuine OFF+ speed from pure all-wood construction with VPS-treated middle veneers improving consistency and looping dwell time, delivering stable flat-trajectory drives.
Emerald VPS V’s stiff construction punishes weak or inconsistent swing technique, with control scores around 7.2—lower than similarly priced all-rounders. Premium pricing approaches composite blades. Heavier weight near 98g can fatigue players in long sessions. Garaydia excels at near-table blocking and control but lacks Emerald VPS V’s long-distance power. Emerald VPS V suits advanced intermediate-to-competitive attackers favoring counter-looping at mid-to-long distance with solid topspin technique. For near-table control mastery, Garaydia ALC is vastly superior.
FAQ
Which excels at long-distance counter-looping?
Emerald VPS V specializes in mid-to-long distance counter-looping. Garaydia’s near-table focus excels at blocking.
How do throwing arcs compare?
Garaydia has very low throw arc optimized for near-table blocking. Emerald VPS V has medium throw angle for stable flat-trajectory drives.
Why is Emerald VPS V so heavy?
Dense all-wood construction with Ebenholz outer and VPS treatment results in 98g weight, causing fatigue in long sessions.
Which is more forgiving?
Garaydia requires precise technique for near-table control. Emerald VPS V’s stiff construction punishes weak or mistimed strokes severely.
Which suits aggressive topspin play better?
Garaydia’s low throw arc lags in topspin generation. Emerald VPS V with VPS-treated veneers improves looping dwell time.