Butterfly Garaydia ALC vs Stiga Carbonado 145: Which Should You Buy?
| Butterfly Garaydia ALC | Stiga Carbonado 145 | |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 8.5/10 | 8.4/10 |
| control | — | — |
| feel | Crisp, hard and stiff with a direct, low-vibration touch and a notably low throw arc | stiff, direct and rather linear with a large sweet spot, but the very thin TeXtreme layers keep the vibration close to a 5-ply all-wood blade |
| handle | FL | FL/ST (also offered as Legend and penhold) |
| plies | 5-ply total: 3 wood + 2 Arylate-Carbon (ALC) layers, with an outer carbon construction under a Japanese hinoki surface ply | 5 wood plus 2 TeXtreme carbon (5+2 composite) with the carbon fibers laid at a 45 degree angle for torsional bendability |
| speed | OFF | OFF+ |
| spin | — | — |
| thickness_mm | 6.9 | 5.7 |
| type | OFF | — |
| weight_g | 83 | 85 |
We may earn a commission from links on this page. Learn more.
Both are stiff carbon blades, but they feel different. The Garaydia ALC uses outer arylate-carbon under hinoki for a crisp, damped, low-throw feel with outstanding near-table stability and control.
The Stiga Carbonado 145 runs two TeXtreme carbon layers yet keeps lab-confirmed wood-like vibration, a large sweet spot and a stiff, fast low-OFF to OFF+ engine with strong mid-distance power and aggressive blocking. It is demanding for players still building consistency.
Choose the Garaydia for damped, low-throw close-table control, the Carbonado 145 for more reach and a bigger sweet spot.
FAQ
Which has the bigger sweet spot?
The Stiga Carbonado 145 is noted for a large, consistent sweet spot, while the Garaydia ALC is valued more for stability and a low throw.
Which is faster from mid-distance?
The Carbonado 145, a low-OFF to OFF+ blade, offers more mid-distance power than the Garaydia, which can feel weak away from the table.